An Insider's Look at Mormon Culture

Predictably, New York City Mayor Bloomberg’s proposal to curb the obesity epidemic by limiting sizes of soft drinks has people screaming that the government has no business dictating the amount of sugar we pour down our gullets. And health care reform bill opponents argue that the government cannot force people to buy health insurance.  Of course, motorcycle riders fight laws to force them to protect their craniums with helmets.

Obviously, government should not restrict the freedom of its citizens without justifiable cause, but does government have a legitimate interest in citizen’s health? Historically, our government has justified laws impacting health for issues of national defense. When the draft was inaugurated at the beginning of World War II, many young men were physically ineligible to serve due to poor nutrition. This caused the federal government to mandate that all white flour be enriched with the vitamins and minerals lost in milling. Fortunately, no one at that time claimed a constitutional right to eat nutrition-free food, and millions of American children escaped rickets and other diseases of malnutrition because of that law.

Governments also have an economic interest in the health of citizens. Sick people are a drag on the economy. Life-saving medical interventions are available in modern America, but they are not free of cost. Our social conscience prevents us from denying emergency care to those who refused to buy health insurance when they were still healthy.  People with obesity-related illnesses and helmet-free motorcycle riders with head injuries cost insurance companies, employers, and public health services money.

Where do we draw the line? Does the fact that my poor health impacts others give government the right to insist that I buy health insurance, limit my soft drink consumption, and protect my brain when engaging in hazardous activities?

For that matter, should my neighbors be free to burn their garbage in their backyard and stink up the neighborhood rather than pay the garbage-hauling fee? And what if said neighbors want to dig an outhouse in their yard rather than pay the city sewage fee?

Living together in a complex society provides many advantages—but close proximity to neighbors means nearly everything we do impacts those around us—and potentially needs regulation.

Comments on: "The Government Has No Business" (4)

  1. Require me to wear a seatbelt? A helmet? Get my car safety inspected? Have proof of rabies vaccination on my dog? Have the wiring inspected while my home is being constructed? Check the produce for contaminants at my grocery store? Swim diapers at the pool? YES!!

    Limit the size of my Diet Coke? PREPOSTEROUS!!

    • Numi,
      I suspect many people draw the line at restricting the size of their soft drinks. Bloomberg has probably ended his political career by picking this battle.

  2. McLerranMD said:

    While I too agree that Bloomberg has most likely committed political sucicide with this effort, in a way I can understand his frustration. Obesity related illnesses drive a large portion of healthcare cost in America and these cost are only going up as more and more Americans become heavier. However legislating personal freedoms and food choices is a volital and exceedingly slippery slope that I cannot see Americans tolerating.

    We may understand that our poor food choices and lack of physical activity leads to obesity, which then leads to numerous health issues, that does not mean we as Americans will allow the Government to tell us what size of soda we can drink.

    I really enjoyed your thoughtfulness with this post. Thanks.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Tag Cloud